Thread display help needed

Started by Bender, December 15, 2008, 08:22:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

CG sailor

 A forum is a means of comunication. Just as if I was standing around talking with some friends about cars. I would rather be there at the start of the conversation than come in half way and try to comment. I would have to ask what was your responce and what was the original question or statement. Since this is written, it should be like what we all grew up doing when we needed to read something.
My second point is: when you voted, how many voted and how long ago was that? I am willing to bet that not many from the POC was on a computer then. Out of the people that voted, how many used this forum site only at the time?
This is a great site for information and I have learned a lot about my car from the members otherwise. I will still visit and post no mater how its set up.
  •  

TodFitch

Quote from: 36ply4dr on December 20, 2008, 08:10:32 PM
1 more vote for 'normal' forum style (Original post is the one you see first).? ?Reads like a book.? If you are new to any topic, you need to know where the conversation starts.? ?If the post is two pages or more it gets even more confusing.? Do I start on page 1? or is page 3 at the bottom where the original post is? makes no sense.? I visit about 30+ forums this is the only one that is 'backwards'

There are a few other forums I visit. And on those that allow individuals to customize their display I set my preferences to have the newest post at the top. So I guess there are a few of us that like it the way it is.

The best of all possible worlds would be for it to be set on a per user basis so you can do as you wish. However I understand that the software that is being used on this site does not support that.
  •  

36ply4dr

1 more vote for 'normal' forum style (Original post is the one you see first).   Reads like a book.  If you are new to any topic, you need to know where the conversation starts.   If the post is two pages or more it gets even more confusing.  Do I start on page 1? or is page 3 at the bottom where the original post is? makes no sense.  I visit about 30+ forums this is the only one that is 'backwards'
  •  

MRR41 COUPE

When you read the post every day its nice to have all the latest replys at my fingertips, I like the thread display the way it is.
  •  

notdavidspade

Not sure what you want here... the topic has been brought up before, people voted that they wanted the posts this way and that?s the way the administrator has it set up.     The "concerns of several the few members" isn't very accurate at all.  One person asked if they could change the order in a setting or some user controlled option.   Within 6 hours, that person got their answer, that there is no option for this.  One person agreed that the ordering of the post is counter to what many other boards do. 

As to this "concern" there really is no advantage to either way of organizing the posts, other than "that?s how everyone else does it".  You either have to scroll through all the responses to see how the tread started, or you have to scroll through all the responses to see what?s been added.  Either way, you have to read though to see what others have written.  If you want to know something in particular, use the search function. 

I'm glad you enjoy the board and I'm sure donations would be appreciated.  Be sure to include a little something extra when you send in your membership application.  I myself am happy the board is here and I?ve found it to be very helpful and useful tool.  If I was given a book about Plymouths, it was free, and it answered all the questions I had about them, I'm not going to complain if the book's paragraphs had to be read from the bottom up. 
  •  

2-Ton

WOW!!
No responce in three days on the concerns of several of the few members.
I'll still check in every week or two, to see if this board is still around.
Sure gives me a warm fuzzy about giving a donation.

BY

2-Ton
Of all the things I have lost in my life,
I miss my mind the most!!

1954 Belvadere 4-door and other cars and trucks of that era.
  •  

2-Ton

Here's a new question.
How many members did this site have when there was a vote a few years back?
(you may have to scroll back down to find out why I ask and then read the small print).?

And what is considered a few years when we are all working on cars that are a little more than a few years old?

When I check in again a few days from now, where should I start reading and repound to concerns that I may have some impact on.

With under 600 members, this site could become a really "tight" group because these cars are not the desired cars for the high dollar collectors.

This is just an observation from a newbe that has other interests for the next few years until I retire and can devote some time to the "54".

2-Ton

Of all the things I have lost in my life,
I miss my mind the most!!

1954 Belvadere 4-door and other cars and trucks of that era.
  •  

CG sailor

Go
Your point is well taken. If I havent been on the site in awhile or try to read a post from the begining, its annoying to have to scroll through everyones responces before I get to the questions. My other point was that no other discussion site is set up like this. Maybe thats what I am use to. Just my 2 pennys.
  •  

Go Fleiter

for every day visitors, this kind of latest addition shown up is good. When following a tread from the beginning, You remember what was said earlier. I don?t need to see the older replys every morning again. Saves a lot of time.

For new members, admitted, this is less comfortable. But in a couple of weeks You will be up to date and enjoy this system.
Greetings! Go
Living in Düsseldorf/Germany, retired Dentist, wife retired lawyer, 2 daughters Judge and psychologist, 3 Grandchilds-Sorry for bad English
I like- PennsyRR- travelling Europe in my very original 51 Ply- My whole basement HO Germany based Model Railroad- 50ties stuff- Italy
  •  

CG sailor

When I first joined this site, I too had trouble figuring out how to use it. I visit a lot of other forums and none are set up this way. It seems backwards to me. I also like the first post on top and then follow the responces. This lets you know the original subject first. Just thought that I would put my two cent in the hat. Great site otherwise.
  •  

2-Ton

I 'm new here and this reverse post doesn't seem right or productive. How can you start with the last thread and know how the topic progressed?
If there are several pages to a good topic, where should someone that does not have time to get on here very often start?
If there is a way to view the first post first, let me know, I like that system better.

Anyway, good site.
When I start restoring my 54 that I bought when I was 19, this will be the place I will be asking questions. I'm one year younger than my car. You do the math on how long I've had this car. (I done forgot or don't want to remember)

Thanks
2-Ton
Of all the things I have lost in my life,
I miss my mind the most!!

1954 Belvadere 4-door and other cars and trucks of that era.
  •  

Bender

Quote from: mopardave on December 15, 2008, 01:02:13 PM
I don't think there is an individual edit to reverse the posting order.? Seems to me we decided on this format a few years back by a vote?? Not sure though.

Thanks. I was going a little nuts looking for it.
Looking for any 33-34 Mopar sheet metal parts

Looking for any 33-35 Dodge or Ply pu sheet metal or chassis parts.

Looking for inline 4x2 intake manifold for a DeSoto hemi.
  •  

Bender

Quote from: plym_46 on December 15, 2008, 11:56:42 AM
by scroling down to the last post in the thread list then using the up button to access the newer posts......

That gives me the newest posts. I want to start with the oldest posts in a thread,and then work my way towards the newest ones. Starting at the newest ones and then going back several pages to get to the start seems counterproductive to me.
Looking for any 33-34 Mopar sheet metal parts

Looking for any 33-35 Dodge or Ply pu sheet metal or chassis parts.

Looking for inline 4x2 intake manifold for a DeSoto hemi.
  •  

mopardave

#3
I don't think there is an individual edit to reverse the posting order.? Seems to me we decided on this format a few years back by a vote?? Not sure though.
1928 Model Q; 1951 Cambridge Club Coupe; 1966 Sport Fury Convertible; 1975 Duster; 1999 Prowler

Johnstown, PA
  •  

plym_46

by scroling down to the last post in the thread list then using the up button to access the newer posts......
  •  

Bender

How do you configure this board to show the first post on a thread first,and then work your way down to the newest one?
Looking for any 33-34 Mopar sheet metal parts

Looking for any 33-35 Dodge or Ply pu sheet metal or chassis parts.

Looking for inline 4x2 intake manifold for a DeSoto hemi.
  •